Subscription Lists

Point of Reference

    by Fred Price

The DaVinci Code And The Role of Women In The Church
Date Posted: December 26, 2003

The best-selling novel, The DaVinci Code, purports to reveal hidden information regarding Jesus Christ and the early church's development within its story-line; adding fuel to the debate concerning the role of women in the church then and now. It repeats allegations that have circulated for centuries; that Mary Magdalene was more than a spiritual supporter of Jesus' ministry, being his lover if not his wife. As a result of her relationship with and understanding of Jesus she supposedly rivaled Peter's leadership of the early church; having lost a power struggle with him she was then relegated to merely being a sinner in need of grace, her particular offense designated as prostitution.

Newsweek Magazine covered this phenomenon in its Dec. 8th issue in a surprisingly balanced manner. One article dealt with a number of assertions in an honest and straightforward manner; assurances were given by leading Biblical, historical and art scholars that the young, beardless, somewhat effeminate individual seated next to Christ in DaVinci's portrayal of The Last Supper was indeed the disciple John – not Mary – he often being depicted beardless and less manly to emphasize his youth. Jesus' possible marriage to Mary is also noted as having no basis in fact or credible innuendo. 1

Contention often centers on the so-called patriarchal system in place during much of our Bible's development and two scriptural injunctions given by Paul concerning the behavior of women in church; as well as his teaching concerning marriage. In 1 Timothy 2:12 he writes, "I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man;…", recalling man – Adam's – status as first born - created and Eve's part in bringing temptation to him and sin to mankind. His remarks in 1 Corinthians 14:34 are more problematic; concerning a woman's silence in church, being taught in detail at home. Although this could in part be referring to the admonition for peace rather than the disorder of debate and argument in church between couples; it probably alludes primarily to the concept of the husband "ruling" over his wife from Genesis 3:16.

However, any unbiased reading of the involved scripture reveals Paul's call for mutual respect and submission of wills between couples, (Ephesians 5:22-23 and 1 Peter 3:1,2,7); with a hierarchy that gives allegiance to Christ first and foremost, acknowledges husbands as head of household and wives as consenting, involved partners. (Or as some say – the husband as head; his wife the neck that turns it!) Some question the necessity of a "leader" at home but any appraisal of successful work endeavors or organizations proves the wisdom of having some form of hierarchy. I honestly believe God creates people to fill roles, differing in particulars but in a broad sense they fit us for enhancing our effectiveness and happiness; women tending to be more emotion driven, spiritually sensitive, considerate, patient, instructive and enabling. These characteristics ideally empower them for supportive ministries that involve training and relational skills. (see 1 Peter 3:15) Men tend to be more demanding and commanding, corrective and inspiring by action; ideal characteristics for motivating, preaching, correcting, persuading ministries. (see 2 Timothy 4:2) Neither ministry is better than the other, however different they may be; their variety allowing them to address a larger number of people and situations. (It is worth noting that twelve men formed the nucleus of Jesus movement, receiving a certain entitlement as a result, however it was women who were recorded as being among the last at the crucifixion and first at the empty tomb as a result of their faithfulness to the person of Jesus.)

Much of this debate revolves around the question of whether scripture was written by men for mankind or inspired by God for mankind's edification; is it the infallible word of God or a fumbling attempt by men to understand God? We may never fully understand all we read in God's word; but if he says it, we must abide by it, hoping to gain understanding and ability through obedience. (Isaiah 55:8) It is beneficial to periodically re-examine our stand on issues to insure we stand on God's word, not man's tradition. Questioning is not wrong as long as we honestly search for answers and accept them when found. Kenneth Woodward noted that, "The test of Biblical scholarship is not how user-friendly it makes the scriptures to groups that feel neglected. Rather it is how well it sheds new light on texts that millions hold to be authoritative."2 Those who seek to use women of the Bible for fulfillment of political agendas ultimately hurt their own cause as gains made through manipulation of facts rarely last.

Criticism is frequently leveled at the Bible's supposed silence concerning the exploits of women, but an honest read of scripture reveals the large influence many women had on the affairs of biblical man – Sarah, Esther and Deborah to name but a few from the Old Testament; Mary the mother of Jesus and Mary – the Apostle to the Apostles, being the first with the resurrection message – Magdalene in the New. Yet our Bibles were never meant to be a series of biographies; lack of detailed information does not denote lack of worth. Jesus and his closest associates, along with Paul are the only New Testament characters who are scrutinized in detail and large segments of time and activity are omitted from their narratives as well; most of the disciples just simply disappear from the written record. This can be terribly frustrating as we wonder why. My personal feeling is that we are given the essentials, which is often more than we can handle and that much of the personal issues we crave would be merely distractive. The non-canonical writings that claim to give detailed histories often deal in fantasy while misguided reverence resulted in the near deification of Jesus' mother – the Apostles and the "saints" of Catholicism. Silence doesn't indicate conspiracy so much as an intent to lessen the opportunity for us to fix our eyes on the temporal rather than the eternal; as we often become over-awed by the exploits of others or complacent in over-familiarity.

Besides – women are mentioned and praised in scripture for their contributions and accomplishments. In particular, the man who advocated silence for women was never-the-less quick to assert his gratitude for their efforts on behalf of the church. He notes Phoebe, "…a servant of the church" and "…a great help to many .."; Priscilla, who opened her home to Paul and the church in Rome and Corinth; Mary, Persis, Tryphena and Tryphosa, as working hard for the Lord; as well as others who were instrumental in advancing the gospel. (Romans 16) (Diakonos, sometimes translated as Deacon, actually meaning servant.)

The core issue is women in the pulpit.3 But do women have to be preaching ministers to have worth in the church? This question will have to be dealt with by today's youth for them to be completely connected to and supportive of the church of Jesus Christ. And therein lies the real issue. It is His church, to rule, administer or dispose of as he sees fit; it is merely ours to obey and grow as we do.

I personally feel women have a key role to fill in today's church; they often being the backbone of many programs and ministries that flourish. My home church's staff lists two women as Department Directors; Children's Education being directed by an energetic, dedicated mother of two and our Music Department led by my wife. Neither woman leads from the pulpit but their ministries are felt throughout the church and community by countless people who don't care who leads in ministry but who is willing to minister. We all are gifted in different ways and suited for different purposes, but we are all expected to find our place, fill that space and support everyone else in their ministry as well. (Romans 12:4-8; 1 Corinthians 12:12-31 and 1 Corinthians 13:1-8)



FOOTNOTES:
1 "Decoding The DaVinci Code", Newsweek, Dec. 8
2 "God's Woman Trouble", Newsweek, Dec. 8
3 Dealt with in part by Pat Wingert and Karen Srpingen in, "The Bible's Lost Stories", Newsweek, Dec. 8

Was this article helpful?
Rate it:

"'Christ in You...'" from Dale Krebbs

Special Calling

Read Article »
Biography Information:

Fred Price - married (50 years), father of two grown children, grandfather of six.

Fred retired earlier this year after 42 years as a factory worker.  He has always had a heart for young people and the challenges they face today.  Over the years Fred has taught Discipleship Groups for High School and college students.  

Got Something to Share?
LiveAsIf.org is always looking for new writers. Whether it is a daily devotional or a weekly article, if you desire to encourage others to know Him better, then signup to become a contributor.